Neela Vermeire Creations – Neith – Not What I Expected

I’m uncertain about Neith. I absolutely loved the brand’s green tuberose fragrance, Eshal, from last year. However, Neith isn’t making as strong an impression on me. It’s a much darker composition than Eshal, and I can’t shake the modern amber wood notes that dominate its base.

Neith opens with a puff of smoke, which actually made me cough the first time I sprayed it. The myrrh and olibanum notes feel overwhelming. The myrrh adds an unexpected sweetness (bordering on too sugary), and beneath all the smoke, I can detect a floral component. This red rose floral note enhances the fragrance’s sweet character. Gradually, this rose deepens until it becomes crimson. It’s syrupy, rich, and opulent. Once my coughing subsides after a few minutes, the next thirty minutes, enhanced by this floral aspect, become the best part of the perfume.

Like other Neela Vermeire scents, I find Neith complex and layered. However, unlike her other creations, I don’t enjoy all of these layers. A carnation note stands out prominently and gives the middle phases an almost medicinal, clove-like quality. The oud note on top of this augments the medicinal feel. Despite castoreum being listed, I don’t experience anything overly animalic. As the floral notes fade, the balance and beauty become disrupted, with the cypriol element heralding a scratchier, woodier base.

Everything after thirty minutes feels like a downhill ski ride to the bottom of a mountain with nothing but woody ambers to cushion me in the outrun. While Neith isn’t a Nagano 98 Hermann Maier-style wipeout, there’s no getting around the fact that this fragrance doesn’t develop like others from the house. It doesn’t bloom. Ducahaufour has padded the base with superfluous woody ambers, which extend longevity and sillage, but I’m not sure they add much to the overall composition. While it’s not the worst use of materials, it feels slightly off for a Neela Vermeire creation—almost as if Mazzy Star suddenly appeared on Headbangers Ball. Everything seems out of sync. As a result, Neith lacks the melodic beauty that characterises some of her other works.

After the carnation and rose wane, things start to tip.

Neith was one of the scents I was most looking forward to trying this year, particularly after all the positive reviews. But it’s a letdown. Perhaps some folk are anosmic to these scratchy bases. So, by all means, try the fragrance, but enter at your own risk. The brand and perfumer have done better. Neith isn’t an out-and-out rose, but it plays a significant role in the scent. For fans of dark, resinous rose scents, I’d recommend checking out Feu de Rose from Reservation Parfums. Even Duchaufour’s own Ensang Noir from his L’Entropiste beats this one out. Both are significantly cheaper than Neith’s 375-euro price tag. Disappointing.

Notes: vetiver, myrrh, rose, oud, cypriol, black pepper, carnation, labdanum, frankincense, opoponax, cedar, castoreum, ambergris, vanilla, sandalwood.

Has anyone else tried this one? Did you pick up the woody ambers?

Note: Bottle image from the brand. All other photos are my own. I purchased the sample of Neith.

12 thoughts on “Neela Vermeire Creations – Neith – Not What I Expected”

  1. You’re correct, Daniel. Neith has drawn a fair amount of favorable feedback, though I haven’t tried it yet. While reviewing the notes, I imagined the storyline and reached nearly the same point: this might be a sweeter amber bomb than expected. I’ll still sample it. Your photos are beautiful as usual.

    1. Thanks, Flaconneur. I’ll be curious to read your thoughts on it. I was quite surprised by the woody amber prominence.

  2. I haven’t tried this one and am hoping to visit the boutique in Paris some day and try all the newer and some of the older ones. I did watch Neela’s recent interview with Persolaise where she explained her intent for Neith. It is meant to be dark and different from the others.
    Many scents that aim to be distinctive these days do still lean on woody ambers, which aren’t always advertised. The nose will find them, though!

    1. That would be a real treat, Nose Prose. Hopefully you get to visit. I haven’t watched that interview yet. I must check it out. But, that would go some of the way to explaining why it smells so different than the others. It seems it was an intentional shift.

  3. You didn’t mention the Neith is impossible to remove once applied! It took 3 long bubble baths to get it to leave the building. Harder to remove than Trump from the White House! To my nose equally repugnant.

    To be fair my expectations were massively high after all the pre-release reviews. Just shows how personal relationships & free stuff influence influencers.

    We’re not alone in our view of Neith. I know of at least one other blogger who finds it difficult. They live by the “if you can’t say anything positive, say nothing mantra”. I suspect there are other bloggers who feel the same. Once the pre-release whoo haa died down there have been few reviews published that I can find. That silence speaks volumes.

    1. Haha. Yea, it’s an extremely stubborn one. I’m glad someone agrees with me on Neith. I couldn’t believe what I was smelling after all the positive reviews. I almost thought I had the wrong sample.

      1. My blogger friend said EXACTLY those words!
        As I say, the radio silence after Neith’s actual release speaks volumes!
        In the month after it arrived in the UK two bottles were listed on eBay UK for less than £200 & sold for less than £150. Another sign of a missed step

        1. Here’s hoping it’s a minor blip on the radar and the brand can get back to producing fragrances that feel more in keeping with their older stuff. Though it almost comes as a relief when I don’t like these expensive perfumes. Neith was an easy pass.

  4. Almost as if Mazzy Star suddenly appeared on Headbangers Ball… love this line, dear Daniel. What a pity this one is a disappointment. Full-on amber-wood can be very tricky for me.

Leave a Reply